14 Nov 2026 | News

Telkom calls for overhaul of Icasa’s BEE ownership rules, says Starlink must face same requirements

Telkom has called for a review of Icasa’s black ownership requirements for telecommunications licence holders, arguing that the regulations extend beyond the country’s broader empowerment framework and risk discouraging investment in network infrastructure.
By Staff Writer

Image: Waldo Swiegers/Bloomberg

Healthtech Connect 2027

In a submission to the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa’s (Icasa) inquiry into individual electronic communications network service (I-ECNS) licences, Telkom questioned whether the regulator’s 2021 Equity Regulations are aligned with the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) Act and the ICT sector code.

The group argues that the regulations impose additional ownership obligations that are not adequately recognised in the broader empowerment framework, creating uncertainty for operators and increasing the cost of regulatory compliance.

Under the existing framework, individual licence holders must maintain at least 30% ownership by historically disadvantaTelkom challenges Icasa’s BEE rules, calls for equal treatment of Starlinkged groups for the duration of their licences and achieve a minimum Level 4 B-BBEE contributor status. The 30% threshold is provided for in the Electronic Communications Act, while a separate black ownership requirement introduced through Icasa’s regulations has been suspended.

Telkom supports the principle of economic transformation but believes compliance should not be measured exclusively through equity ownership. It has proposed recognising other contributions, including skills development, local procurement, infrastructure investment and funding for research and innovation.

The company warned that the current regulatory uncertainty could constrain competition and discourage investment in telecommunications infrastructure at a time when South Africa needs greater network capacity.

Starlink debate raises questions about regulatory parity

The submission also adds to the debate over the licensing of satellite operators, particularly Elon Musk’s Starlink, which has yet to secure approval to operate in South Africa.

Communications Minister Solly Malatsi issued a policy direction in December 2025 calling on Icasa to reconsider its ownership requirements and align them with the B-BBEE Act and the ICT sector code.

The proposed changes could provide an alternative route for multinational operators to meet transformation requirements through equity-equivalent investment programmes (EEIPs). These allow qualifying companies to contribute to empowerment objectives through investments in areas such as skills development, enterprise support and infrastructure rather than transferring equity to local shareholders.

Telkom, however, has emphasised that any regulatory concessions should apply equally to existing operators and new market entrants.

It argues that satellite companies seeking to provide services directly to South African customers should face the same licensing conditions and social obligations as established telecommunications businesses.

These requirements include individual network and electronic communications service licences, as well as the necessary spectrum authorisations.

Telkom identified Starlink, Amazon Leo, Spacesail, Eutelsat OneWeb and Avanti Communications as potential entrants that should be subject to consistent regulatory treatment.

The company warned that introducing different compliance arrangements for new operators could create a two-tier regulatory environment, disadvantaging established businesses that have already invested substantially in meeting local licensing and empowerment obligations.

Industry seeks clarity on transformation requirements

Telkom’s position is broadly consistent with concerns raised by the Association of Comms & Technology (ACT), which represents Telkom, Vodacom, MTN, Cell C, Rain and Liquid Intelligent Technologies.

The industry body has supported the use of equity-equivalent investment programmes but has argued that companies should operate under a consistent set of regulatory conditions.

Telkom’s submission goes further by challenging the design of Icasa’s existing ownership regulations, rather than focusing only on how the proposed policy changes should be implemented.

The outcome of the review could have significant implications for the structure of foreign investment in South Africa’s telecommunications sector, particularly as satellite operators seek access to the local market.

Telkom has also questioned whether issuing additional individual network licences would materially improve competition. It argues that the potential impact of new licensees would be limited.

Icasa has taken a different preliminary view. In a discussion document published on 30 October 2026, the regulator indicated that prospective network operators should be allowed to apply directly for individual licences.

The regulator now faces the challenge of balancing transformation objectives with the need to attract investment, encourage competition and maintain a consistent regulatory framework as new technologies and international operators enter the market.

Press contact
Tech Review
Telkom calls for overhaul of Icasa’s BEE ownership rules, says Starlink must face same requirements | Tech Review Africa